Home  /  Insights  /  Broker, Advisor, or Investment Bank
Seller Guide · Your Advisor

Business broker, M&A advisor, or investment bank: which do you need?

The labels overlap, but the sales they run don’t. The right choice depends mostly on your company’s size and who is likely to buy it.

By David W. McCombie III

Founder & CEO, McCombie Group · Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024)

Last reviewed November 2026 · About 8 minutes

Selling Your Business with Confidence, by David W. McCombie III (Wiley, 2024)

The short answer

It depends mostly on size. Business brokers usually sell smaller, owner-run businesses by listing them with an asking price, often to individual buyers. M&A advisors and investment banks run a confidential, competitive process for larger companies, aimed at private equity firms and corporate buyers. Once a company is worth around $10 million or more, owners are usually better served by an M&A advisor.

What’s the difference between a business broker, an M&A advisor, and an investment bank?

The three overlap, and the labels get used loosely. The useful distinction is the kind of sale each one is built to run.

Exhibit 1

Brokers sell listings to individual buyers; M&A advisors or investment banks run confidential auctions for professional buyers

Business brokerM&A advisor or investment bank
Typical businessSmaller, owner-run businesses, generally below about $10 million in valueEstablished companies with a management team, usually worth $10 million or more
Typical buyerAn individual looking to buy and run a business, often with a bank loan backed by the Small Business Administration (SBA)Private equity firms, corporate buyers, family offices, with their lenders
How it’s marketedA listing with an overview and an asking price, posted where buyers browseTargeted, confidential outreach; no asking price; buyers bid in rounds
How value is measuredOften seller’s discretionary earnings, which adds back all of the owner’s pay. Because the base is larger, multiples of it run much lower than EBITDA multiples for the same business, so the two can’t be compared directlyAdjusted EBITDA, which assumes a market salary for every role
What’s preparedA summary and basic financialsA full offering memorandum, financial model, and data room, prepared after the advisor diligences the business
How they’re paidA commission at closing, often 8% to 12%, usually with no retainerA retainer plus a success fee that declines with size; see our fee guide
General patterns; firms vary. Adapted from David W. McCombie III, Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024), chapter 5. Copyright © 2025 by MG Publishing, LLC. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Brokers fill a real need. Most M&A advisors and investment banks can’t serve deals under about $10 million profitably, and many set minimums well above that. For a smaller business sold to an individual operator, a good broker who can help a buyer line up financing may be exactly right.

Is an M&A advisor the same as an investment bank?

In the middle market, mostly yes. Sell-side M&A advisors are often investment banks, and the two terms are used interchangeably. Large Wall Street banks are a different business. They focus on much larger deals, and they are essential if your company is going public. A middle-market sale is small for them, so many won’t take it on, and those that do often treat it as a training assignment for junior staff.

Why the choice matters for an established company

A listing with an asking price works when the buyer is one person buying a job. It works poorly when the best buyers are professionals who review dozens of companies for every one they buy. Those buyers respond to competition, or the credible threat of it. An advisor creates it by reaching many buyers confidentially, keeping them on the same timeline, and making each one bid knowing others are bidding too.

An asking price creates two problems. It caps your upside, because a buyer has little reason to offer more than the number you named. And if it’s set too high, it can scare away legitimate buyers who never make an offer at all. One of the most valuable things a competitive process does is price discovery: the market, not a guess, sets the price.

We’ve met owners who didn’t know there was a difference. One hired a business broker who knew the SBA loan process for smaller deals well, but not what is market when selling to an institutional buyer. The broker found buyers, but ran no competitive process, and the price reflected it. The owner did most of the heavy lifting, including the accounting, while the broker acted mainly as a conduit. A good broker is the right fit for many smaller businesses. The mistake is hiring for the wrong size of deal.

Video · 2:588 Ways Selling a Business is Different than Selling Your Home Eight reasons a company sale works nothing like a home sale. Read the transcript

No one bids their best price when they know they’re the only one at the table.

Do you need an M&A advisor at all?

As an entrepreneur, you could certainly figure it out and sell the company yourself. But it is usually the most expensive money you will ever save. A properly run sale takes more than 1,000 hours, you would be negotiating against buyers who do this for a living, and you would be doing it while running the business at full speed. When performance slips during a sale, buyers notice, and offers often come down. Published research finds advised private sellers tend to get meaningfully higher prices; our fee guide covers the studies.

Your range

Not sure which side of the line you’re on?

Get Your Range gives you a preliminary value range from a few inputs you already know.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

How to choose an M&A advisor

No license or credential tells you who is good at this. Start with recommendations from other owners and your attorney or CPA, then interview two or three advisors. Expect it to be a two-way interview. Because most of their pay comes from a success fee, the best advisors have to be selective about the engagements they take on. Beyond the size of the fee, they weigh how committed you are to selling, whether your expectations are realistic, how marketable the business is, whether you’ll rely on their advice, your reputation and integrity, whether their experience fits your business, and whether the personalities work.

  1. Pick a firm that works at your size. Each deal size has its own buyers, lenders, and norms. A firm focused on your range is more likely to treat your sale as important, not as a small assignment.
  2. Ask who will actually do the work. Senior people often pitch the engagement and then hand it off. Find out who leads, who negotiates, and how many other deals they are running.
  3. Don’t hire the highest valuation. Some advisors win engagements by quoting a number they know is unlikely, then blame diligence when it doesn’t arrive. By then you are usually locked into the engagement, plus its tail: a period after the engagement ends during which the advisor still gets credit, and a fee, if you sell.
  4. Call references, including deals that didn’t close. Failed deals often teach you more about an advisor than successful ones.
  5. Ask for their plan for your business. A tailored process, with reasons behind it, beats a standard one. Be wary of claims of a secret list of buyers: the industry’s open secret is that almost all advisors have similar reach, and serious buyers answer any credible advisor’s call.
  6. Weigh specialist against generalist. An industry specialist knows the buyers well; a generalist may push harder and reach buyers from other industries. If you choose a specialist, keep in mind that they work with the same buyers deal after deal. Make sure protecting those relationships never outweighs pushing for the best price for you.

In the end it comes down to trust: that they will put your interests ahead of getting a deal done, keep your information private, tell you hard truths, and get your input before making decisions that matter.

Owner questions about choosing an advisor

Do I need an M&A advisor in Florida, or can I use one from anywhere?

Buyers for established companies are national and often international, so what matters most is experience with companies your size and in your industry. A nearby advisor can still help: meeting in person, visiting your facilities, and knowing local lenders, attorneys, and CPAs. We are based in Coral Gables and work with founders across Florida and beyond.

At what size should I hire an M&A advisor instead of a broker?

There’s no hard line, but once a company is worth around $10 million, has a management team, and would appeal to private equity or corporate buyers, an M&A advisor’s competitive process usually fits better than a listing, and tends to deliver a much higher return on the fees involved.

How much do business brokers charge compared with M&A advisors?

Brokers commonly charge a commission of around 8% to 12% at closing with no retainer. The percentage is high because their typical deal sizes are small. M&A advisors usually charge a retainer plus a success fee that declines with size, roughly 5.5% to 6% around $10 million. Our fee guide has the full curve.

Can my CPA or attorney sell my business?

They are essential members of your deal team, but running a sale is a different job: finding and reaching buyers, creating competition, and negotiating price and terms. Most owners use an advisor to run the process, a transaction attorney for the documents, and their CPA and a tax specialist alongside.

How long is a typical engagement?

A well-prepared sale typically runs eight to nine months from preparation to closing, so plan for up to twelve. Engagement letters usually run six to twelve months and renew automatically, which matters if the sale takes longer than expected: check the renewal and termination terms before you sign.

Go deeper

Background reading. Figures reflect when each piece was published.

This guide is general education, not legal, tax, or accounting advice. Published October 2026.

David W. McCombie III, Founder & Chief Executive Officer of McCombie Group
Expertise

Led by the person who wrote the book on selling a business.

David W. McCombie IIIFounder & Chief Executive Officer

Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024).

David also serves on the executive committee of the Miami chapter of YPO, the global community of chief executives.

Selling Your Business with Confidence-- David W. McCombie III, published by Wiley

Know your range before you interview advisors.

A confidential conversation, or a realistic view of your range. Both are free, and both are useful even if you do nothing for years.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

Start a Confidential Conversation

Most owners who talk to us aren’t selling yet.