Home  /  Insights  /  Quality of Earnings
Seller Guide · Your Numbers

Quality of earnings: should you get one before you sell?

The best reason to get a quality of earnings review isn’t a higher multiple. It’s no surprises: a realistic number, tested before a buyer tests it, on a deal that closes.

By David W. McCombie III

Founder & CEO, McCombie Group · Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024)

Last reviewed November 2026 · About 11 minutes

Selling Your Business with Confidence, by David W. McCombie III (Wiley, 2024)

The short answer

A quality of earnings (QoE) report is an accountant’s independent rebuild of your adjusted profit, tied to your bank statements and tax returns. Don’t expect it to raise your multiple. Its real value is to minimize surprises: a number that holds up when a buyer’s accountants test it, on a deal that closes.

What is a quality of earnings report?

A quality of earnings report answers one question: how much does this business really earn, year after year, under a new owner? Accountants rebuild your annual profit before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) from your general ledger, then tie it to your bank statements and tax returns. Along the way they test every adjustment you claim (your add-backs). They also test whether those earnings are sustainable by looking at the drivers underneath them: the working capital the business needs and, in particular, the quality of your revenue, including how steady it is, where it comes from, and how long your customers stay.

It is not an audit or a review, and the difference matters. An audit or review asks whether your past statements follow accounting rules. A QoE asks what a buyer can expect to earn after closing.

Exhibit 1

An audit or review, your own QoE, and the buyer’s QoE answer three different questions

Audit or reviewSell-side QoEBuyer’s QoE
The questionDo past statements follow accounting rules?What will a buyer accept as our real, repeatable profit?Is the profit we’re paying for real, and what could go wrong?
Who hires itThe company, usually every yearThe owner, before going to marketThe buyer, after the letter of intent
What it producesAn opinion (audit) or limited assurance (review) on the financial statementsAdjusted EBITDA you can defend, with each add-back supportedThe buyer’s version of your adjusted EBITDA, plus a list of concerns
Who it works forOwners and lendersYouThe buyer, whose advisors are paid to find problems
General patterns. Scope varies by firm and engagement.

The buyer will do one anyway. The question is who goes first.

Once you sign a letter of intent (LOI), the leverage shifts to the buyer and the tone changes. You have agreed to stop talking to other buyers, and the buyer moves from courting you to scrutinizing you. Until then the buyer has seen a curated picture: your offering materials, a few calls, one management meeting. Now real money is at stake, and the buyer hires accountants, lawyers, and other specialists to verify everything. Their accountants’ job is to find anything that lowers the price or justifies walking away.

That is fair. You would do the same before a purchase this size. But it means the letter of intent is usually the best price you will see. After it, changes tend to run one way. A sell-side QoE is how you find and fix what their accountants would find, while you still control the timing and the story.

Does a quality of earnings report raise the price?

Many owners are told that a sell-side QoE earns a higher multiple. GF Data, which tracks prices and terms reported by private equity buyers, began recording sell-side QoE reports in mid-2024. Across 2025 and 2026, once you compare deals of similar size, the gap between deals with and without a QoE runs from about −0.2× to +0.4× EBITDA.

At the end of the day, a QoE has basically no impact on the multiple: deals with and without one sell for about the same price.

What the price data can’t see: the deals that didn’t close

In World War II, military analysts mapped the bullet holes on bombers returning from missions and proposed adding armor where the holes clustered. The statistician Abraham Wald saw the flaw: they were only looking at the planes that made it home. Planes hit in the engines mostly didn’t come back, so the engines, where returning planes showed the fewest holes, were where armor mattered most.

Deal data has the same blind spot. Any comparison of deal multiples, including the one above, counts only the deals that closed. A deal that fell apart in diligence over a surprise in the numbers, the exact problem a QoE is built to catch, never shows up in the average. A deal re-priced after a surprise simply shows up as a lower-priced deal.

Exhibit 2

Price comparisons count only the deals that made it home, not the ones a QoE might have kept alive

What a price comparison counts

  • Deals that closed
  • The price at closing, after any cuts made in diligence
  • Whether the company had a QoE

What it can’t see

  • Deals that fell apart in diligence
  • Whether a price was cut between the letter of intent and closing
  • The months, money, and leverage lost when a sale has to start over
McCombie Group view of what a comparison of closed-deal multiples can and can’t measure.

So the data answers a narrow question: among deals that closed, did the ones with a QoE price higher? It can’t answer the question that matters more to an owner: did the review keep the deal alive, and the price intact? In our experience, it often does. A QoE improves the odds that a deal closes, so it adds real value. It just doesn’t show up in the multiple.

David learned this the hard way early in my career. We took a client to market relying on his own financials. When the first diligence questions came in, buyers asked about aged receivables. They turned out to be phantom revenue that should never have been booked. Profit was lower than the owner believed, and so was the price he expected. The buyer was put off by the price gap and even more by the lack of controls, and the deal fell apart. That deal never appears in anyone’s price data.

The real payoff: no surprises, even when the news isn’t what you hoped

The most valuable thing a sell-side QoE can do is tell you the truth early. Sometimes that truth is that your adjusted profit is lower than the number you have been carrying in your head: an add-back that won’t hold, a year-end entry that flattered a good year, a large customer that is unlikely to renew.

That is hard to hear. It is far better to hear it from your own accountants, months before you go to market, than from a buyer’s accountants after you have signed a letter of intent and stopped talking to anyone else. By then the choices are a lower price, negotiated under pressure, or starting over. Hearing it early keeps your options open. If the number is lower than you hoped, you can deliberately delay the sale and work on raising the value until you can reach an outcome that meets your goals. Our Institutional Grade program is built for that runway: we help you prioritize the changes that move value, prepare the business for a buyer’s diligence, and track your value over time so you can choose your moment.

It can also mean accepting a price below the one you had anchored on. Setting expectations from tested numbers is how you avoid having them reset for you.

A realistic number that closes is worth more than a bigger number that falls apart in diligence.

Beyond no surprises, a sell-side QoE tends to buy you four things.

  1. Add-backs that hold. You find the weak adjustments before a buyer does, and decide what to fix, document, or drop. Every adjustment that survives is worth a multiple of itself: defending $300,000 of add-backs a buyer would otherwise challenge is worth about $2.1 million of price at seven times profit, even if the multiple never moves. Our guide to add-backs walks through the arithmetic.
  2. Speed. Time is the enemy of a signed deal: the longer diligence runs, the more chances something slips. A partner at a firm that prepares these reports told ACG that a sell-side QoE moves the deal faster more than 90% of the time (ACG, December 2025).
  3. A shorter leash on exclusivity. Once you sign, you can’t talk to other buyers. When the answers are already prepared, you can hold a buyer to a tighter timeline.
  4. More cash at closing. Clean, tested financials make it easier to insure the seller’s promises in the purchase agreement via Rep and Warranty insurance (RWI). In the same GF report, insured deals held back an average of 2.6% of the price after closing, versus 10.7% for uninsured deals.

When a sell-side QoE is worth it, and when it may not be

Not every company needs one. Unlike many advisors, we prepare a financial recast and databook for our clients, which covers much of the same analysis. A formal QoE is still warranted when the numbers are complicated, or when an independent third party’s validation would carry extra weight with buyers. These are the signals we weigh:

Exhibit 3

The more your adjusted profit depends on judgment calls, the more a sell-side QoE tends to pay for itself

Signs it likely pays for itself

  • Add-backs are large relative to reported EBITDA
  • Your financials have never been audited or reviewed
  • Books kept on a cash basis, or year-end entries that move profit around
  • Fast growth, a recent acquisition, or a big new contract
  • Several entities, or business with companies you also own
  • Inventory or receivables that swing a lot during the year
  • You expect private equity buyers, who will run a deep review

Signs a careful CPA review may be enough

  • Several years of audited or reviewed financials
  • Few add-backs, each with clean documentation
  • One entity with simple, steady operations
  • Monthly books closed on time and on an accrual basis
  • A likely buyer that already knows your business well
McCombie Group view. The decision depends on your numbers, your buyers, and your timeline.

Your numbers

Want to see what buyers might pay on your adjusted profit?

Get Your Range gives you a preliminary value range from a few inputs you already know.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

How to get the most out of a sell-side QoE

  • Start early. Accountants who do this work suggest starting three to six months before you go to market (ACG, December 2025), so findings can be fixed and every number in your offering materials matches the report.
  • Choose a firm with the qualifications and capabilities to do this correctly. Consider a transaction accounting team rather than your regular tax CPA. This is specialized work that transaction specialists do faster and better. Most generalist accountants are focused on minimizing your taxes, while a Transaction Advisory accountant focuses on the unique nuances of transactions. Buyers will still do their own homework with their own accountants, but a well-known firm’s name on the report gives them some extra comfort.
  • Set the scope with the buyer in mind: adjusted EBITDA, the working capital the business normally needs, a cash test against bank statements, revenue by customer, and any debt-like items.
  • Act on what it finds, and believe it. If it flags a weak add-back, fix it, document it, or drop it before a buyer sees your numbers. If it says your adjusted profit is lower than you hoped, reset your expectations now, while the only cost is a revised number.
  • Keep it current. If diligence starts months after the report, buyers will ask for the latest months. Plan to update it.

Our own work starts the same way. Before any buyer sees a number, we test the business the way a buyer’s accountants will, so there is time to fix what we find.

Owner questions about quality of earnings

How is a quality of earnings report different from an audit?

An audit or review tests whether your historical statements follow accounting rules. A QoE tests whether your adjusted profit is real and sustainable for a new owner: it supports each add-back and ties profit to your bank statements and tax returns. Buyers usually run a QoE, even on audited or reviewed companies.

Does a sell-side QoE increase the sale price?

Not in the multiple. GF Data’s figures on private equity deals show that once you compare deals of similar size, there is little to no price premium for having a QoE. Its value shows up elsewhere: less risk, add-backs that survive, fewer price cuts after the letter of intent, and better odds that the deal closes.

What if my QoE comes back lower than I expected?

Then it did its job. A lower number found by your own accountants, before you go to market, gives you time to fix what can be fixed, document what can be defended, and reset expectations on the rest. The same finding from a buyer’s accountants after a letter of intent usually means a price cut negotiated under pressure, or a deal that falls apart.

Will the buyer still do their own QoE?

Almost always, yes. Most buyers and their lenders want their own accountants’ sign-off. A good sell-side report tends to make the buyer’s review faster and narrower, because the work and the support are already organized and documented. In effect, you hand the buyer’s accountants the work on a silver platter, and their job becomes double-checking it rather than building it from scratch.

What does a QoE cost?

It depends on the size and complexity of your books, the scope, and the firm. We’ve seen smaller firms charge as little as $30,000 to $40,000, and Big Four accounting firms charge several hundred thousand dollars. Ask for a fixed fee with a defined scope, then weigh it against what it protects: at seven times profit, keeping $100,000 of add-backs from being rejected is worth about $700,000 of price.

When should I start a quality of earnings review?

Before you go to market, typically three to six months ahead, and before your offering materials are final. Starting after a buyer is involved defeats the purpose: you lose the chance to fix what it finds.

What will the accountants ask for?

Expect your general ledger detail, bank statements, tax returns, payroll records, receivable and payable agings, inventory records, revenue by customer for several years, and the documents behind each add-back. Our due diligence checklist covers the full list.

Go deeper

Background reading. Figures reflect when each piece was published.

This guide is general education, not legal, tax, or accounting advice. GF Data figures are averages across private equity deals that closed and were reported to GF; they do not predict any one company’s outcome. Published October 2026.

David W. McCombie III, Founder & Chief Executive Officer of McCombie Group
Expertise

Led by the person who wrote the book on selling a business.

David W. McCombie IIIFounder & Chief Executive Officer

Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024).

David also serves on the executive committee of the Miami chapter of YPO, the global community of chief executives.

Selling Your Business with Confidence-- David W. McCombie III, published by Wiley

Know your range before a buyer’s accountants test it.

A confidential conversation, or a realistic view of your range. Both are free, and both are useful even if you do nothing for years.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

Start a Confidential Conversation

Most owners who talk to us aren’t selling yet.