Home  /  Insights  /  Offers and Buyers (Videos)
Video · Short Videos

Offers and buyers: four short videos

Why offers aren’t equal, how to read a buyer’s seriousness, why offers should arrive together, and how much price really matters.

By David W. McCombie III

Founder & CEO, McCombie Group · Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024)

4 short videos, about 6 minutes in all, with transcripts

Selling Your Business with Confidence, by David W. McCombie III (Wiley, 2024)

A letter of intent is only as good as the buyer behind it. These four short videos cover what sits behind an offer, each with its transcript.

All offers are not equal

Video · 0:50All Offers Are Not Created Equal An offer is only as valuable as the rigor the buyer put into it.

All offers are not created equal. An offer is only as valuable as the rigor the buyer put into it. What I mean is that it’s very easy for a buyer to take a template and make an offer in 30 minutes or so. Most offers, 99% of them, are non-binding, so many buyers view this process as a free option. In other words, if they like what they see, they’ll continue along, but if not, they’ll drop out of the process, regardless of the damage done to you and your business. It’s extremely important to lean on your advisor to understand the reputation of the buyer, so you can make an informed decision before signing that letter of intent.

Is the buyer serious?

Video · 2:20Determining a Prospective Buyer’s Level of Seriousness and Likelihood of Closing How to tell a serious buyer from a tire kicker.

In any process, there are a number of buyers where it quickly becomes apparent they’re not legitimate. They’re tire kickers. The easiest way to identify them is to look at their track record. If they’ve never really deployed capital, at large but specifically in the industry, there’s a lower probability they’re actually going to follow through.

But there are other warning signs. When somebody goes through a process, or even signs a letter of intent, very little commitment is required from the buyer, at least at that point. It’s a free option. One mistake a lot of sellers make is assuming a buyer has the same level of commitment to the process that they do, because of how important the transaction is to them. The reality is that buyers can easily sign a letter of intent after doing very little homework and treat it as a free option. If they really like what they see, they proceed. If they don’t, they can easily walk away.

So one of the factors we constantly look for when assessing the actual likelihood that somebody’s going to close is how much time and effort the buyer has really put into looking at this opportunity. For example, what types of questions are they asking? How deep are the questions? From the data room, we can often see how many times they’ve accessed it, along with various other actions. What’s their pattern of following up? How proactive are they? These indicators are qualitative, but they help us develop a perspective on how serious a buyer actually is in the process.

And you have to remember that, at the end of the day, your offer only has as much value as the rigor the buyer put into making it. If they have no intention of following through, it’s just a nice sheet of paper.

Synchronizing offers

Video · 0:49Synchronizing Offers Why a good process brings every offer in at the same time.

An underappreciated but critical element of a sale process is synchronizing the various offers. What I mean is that no potential buyer gets too far ahead of the others. If one does, you’re put in the uncomfortable position of deciding between this offer, which may not be great, and declining it to wait for something better. Consequently, one of the most important parts of the art of M&A that your investment banker will practice is using their discretion to slow down and speed up the various offers, so you can make an educated decision with everything in front of you at the same time.

How important is price?

Video · 2:23How Important Is Price? John Chung and David on why the decision to transact matters more than the price.

John: And David, the other thing you and I have talked about often is that when you do a transaction and look back on it four or five years later, the decision to transact is much more important than the price you transact at. If it’s wrong to sell at 100, it’s wrong to sell at 125 or 130. If it’s wrong to buy at 50, it’s usually wrong to buy at 30. The numbers, over time, are more forgiving than the decision itself, because fundamentally of the compounding nature of either a correct decision or a wrong decision.

David: That sounds consistent with Charlie Munger and Warren Buffett, really preferring high-quality businesses with a moat, even if they have to pay a fair price. I’d rather get a great business and pay well for it than get a mediocre business at a really good discount.

John: Right. And talking to sellers, you really can’t do much about timing, David. If you’re a 70-year-old owner and you want to stay active but you don’t want to run the business, and you want to sell, you just want the best execution you can get at that particular moment in time. It may not be the best in terms of the value you’re going to get compared to, let’s say, what happened in the last several years. So you do the best you can. And within the idea of doing the best you can, there are a lot of small judgments you have to exercise, and hopefully in the process, whether you do it with an advisor or yourself, you exercise the proper judgment.

This transcript was lightly edited for readability: filler words removed and paragraphs added; the meaning is unchanged. Bracketed notes were added for this page, and […] marks a short passage left out. General education, not legal, tax, or investment advice.

David W. McCombie III, Founder & Chief Executive Officer of McCombie Group
Expertise

Led by the person who wrote the book on selling a business.

David W. McCombie IIIFounder & Chief Executive Officer

Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024).

David also serves on the executive committee of the Miami chapter of YPO, the global community of chief executives.

Selling Your Business with Confidence-- David W. McCombie III, published by Wiley

Have every offer read by someone on your side.

A confidential conversation, or a realistic view of your range. Both are free, and both are useful even if you do nothing for years.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

Start a Confidential Conversation

Most owners who talk to us aren’t selling yet.