Home  /  Insights  /  Why Is It Hard to Value a Business?
Video · Valuation

Why is it so hard to value my business?

Few truly comparable sales exist. Size, timing, fundamentals, deal terms, and accounting all distort the comparison.

By David W. McCombie III

Founder & CEO, McCombie Group · Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024)

Published July 24, 2024 · Video, 3 min 23 sec, with transcript

Selling Your Business with Confidence, by David W. McCombie III (Wiley, 2024)

Watch the video

Video · 3:23Why Is It So Difficult to Value My Business? Why truly comparable sales are rare, and five ways comparisons go wrong.

Valuing a private company is more art than science. Why the comparable transactions people cite so often aren’t comparable at all.

Transcript

The reason it’s so difficult to get a truly accurate valuation is, A, there’s a lack of data, and B, there’s a lack of comparability between the various elements. I find in most of my engagements that when you peel back the onion, you typically have a true peer set of maybe two, one, or maybe not a single company that really reflects the business’s true value. I’m going to go through a handful of areas where I find there can be big discrepancies between valuation and the comparability of businesses.

The first is business size. As we’ve discussed in prior videos, larger businesses tend to trade at much higher multiples than smaller ones, and the available public information on transactions tends to skew toward much larger businesses. So what you see in a Fortune 500 company is likely going to be far off from the true valuation of a smaller, lower middle market business. What you typically see in Fortune 500 businesses is a much higher multiple than their lower middle market cousins. What happens is people will often apply the multiple they see from the big publicly traded companies, but they can be off by 4 or 5x.

The second discrepancy you often find is timing. You may have a multiple that’s two, three, or four years old, set in a very different environment from today’s market in terms of interest rates, macroeconomic conditions, and so on.

You also have a number of differences in business fundamentals. Look at your industry, and against any other business you’ll see a wide range of strategies, industry segments, growth rates, and cultures. All of these factors make it very difficult to compare businesses on an apples-to-apples basis.

The other element I want to talk about is the accuracy, or precision, of the terms being used. Many people will throw around a multiple, but the question is: does that multiple reflect the entire value, or just the cash value? And what are the terms of the elements that may not be cash? For example, does it have an earnout? Is that earnout achievable or not? These factors make it very difficult to say these two businesses’ multiples are comparable. Similarly, you often find discrepancies in accounting, where the same business in the same industry could have different accounting treatment for different things. And there’s the measurement period. When someone says, “I sold it at 10x,” was that off last year, the last 12 months, or projected future earnings?

When you take all these things together, you see that it’s very easy to have wide discrepancies in valuations, because it’s difficult to fully understand whether we’re talking apples to apples.

This transcript was lightly edited for readability: filler words removed and paragraphs added; the meaning is unchanged. Bracketed notes were added for this page, and […] marks a short passage left out. General education, not legal, tax, or investment advice.

David W. McCombie III, Founder & Chief Executive Officer of McCombie Group
Expertise

Led by the person who wrote the book on selling a business.

David W. McCombie IIIFounder & Chief Executive Officer

Author of Selling Your Business with Confidence (Wiley, 2024).

David also serves on the executive committee of the Miami chapter of YPO, the global community of chief executives.

Selling Your Business with Confidence-- David W. McCombie III, published by Wiley

Get a range built for your business, not an average.

A confidential conversation, or a realistic view of your range. Both are free, and both are useful even if you do nothing for years.

Get Your Range

Free and confidential: about two minutes of questions, then a preliminary value range by email.

Start a Confidential Conversation

Most owners who talk to us aren’t selling yet.